Why is the Vice President of Human Resources so rarely included in a company’s group of most powerful vice presidents?
Vice President of Human Resources
Full Answer Section
-
Focus on Data and Analytics: HR is embracing data and analytics, demonstrating the impact of HR initiatives on key business metrics like employee retention, productivity, and innovation.
-
Employee Experience as a Business Driver: The rise of the employee experience as a key differentiator in attracting and retaining talent has elevated HR's importance, making it a strategic partner in driving business growth.
While the VP HR might not always hold the same level of perceived power as other C-suite executives, their role is increasingly becoming recognized as critical to organizational success. As HR continues to evolve and demonstrate its strategic value, the VP HR's influence within the organization is likely to grow.
Sample Answer
The Vice President of Human Resources (VP HR) is often perceived as less powerful than other C-suite executives, primarily due to several factors:
-
Perceived Soft Skills Focus: HR is often seen as focused on "soft" skills like employee relations, training, and culture, which are less quantifiable and tangible compared to the revenue-generating functions of finance, sales, or marketing. This can create a perception that HR is less directly tied to business success.
-
Lack of Direct P&L Responsibility: VP HR typically doesn't have a profit-and-loss (P&L) responsibility, unlike heads of departments directly generating revenue. This can limit their influence in strategic decision-making where financial performance is a primary driver.
-
Historical Focus on Administrative Tasks: Traditionally, HR departments were viewed as primarily administrative, handling tasks like payroll, benefits, and compliance. While this focus has evolved, the legacy of being seen as primarily transactional can linger.
-
Perception of Being a Service Department: HR is often viewed as a service department, providing support to other departments rather than driving core business strategy. This can lead to a perception of being less essential for overall business success.
-
Power Dynamics: The power dynamics within an organization can also contribute to the perceived lack of influence of VP HR. In some companies, a strong CEO or CFO might overshadow the VP HR, limiting their involvement in strategic decisions.
However, this perception is increasingly changing:
-
Shift Towards Strategic HR: Modern HR departments are increasingly recognized for their strategic role in driving business success. They play a crucial role in talent acquisition, development, engagement, and fostering a positive work environment, all of which are essential for organizational performance.