Option 1: Discuss the threats to general aviation (GA).
Do you think there is a serious threat from terrorism? Why or why not?
Why are GA security programs implemented in GA airports? Explain your answers.
Option 2: Discuss the AOPA Airport Watch program.
Do you think this is effective in the prevention of crime and terrorism? Why or why not?
Threats to general aviation (GA).
Full Answer Section
- Aircraft Size: Payload capacity of GA aircraft is limited compared to commercial jets.
However, GA aircraft could still be used for smaller-scale attacks or as a training tool for terrorists.
GA Security Programs:
Despite a lower overall threat level, GA security programs are important because:
- Deterrence: Security measures like fencing and access control make it more difficult for criminals and terrorists to target GA airports.
- Layered Security: GA security complements commercial aviation security, creating a more comprehensive national defense system.
- Public Safety: Even a small GA aircraft can cause significant damage if used for malicious purposes. Security programs help mitigate this risk.
Option 2: AOPA Airport Watch Program
The Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association (AOPA) Airport Watch Program encourages pilots and airport personnel to be vigilant and report any suspicious activity.
Effectiveness:
- Strengths: Extra eyes and ears on the ground can be very effective in deterring crime and identifying potential threats.
- Challenges: Reliance on volunteers and the subjective nature of "suspicious" activity can limit effectiveness.
Overall, the AOPA program is a valuable tool but should be seen as one part of a larger GA security strategy.
Sample Answer
Option 1: Threats and Security Programs in General Aviation
Threats to GA:
- Theft: Light aircraft are seen as easier targets for theft and illegal resale compared to larger commercial jets.
- Unauthorized Use: Stolen GA aircraft could be used for illegal activities or even as weapons in terrorist attacks.
- Sabotage: Tampering with GA aircraft could pose a serious safety risk.
Terrorism Threat:
While possible, using a GA aircraft for a large-scale terrorist attack is considered less likely than using commercial airliners due to:
- Pilot Training: Acquiring a pilot's license requires training and background checks, making it harder for terrorists to infiltrate