http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/whenkidsgetlife/
write about your impression of the film,
topic,
its relation to the course,
and your understanding of the following:
· What is the impact of this issue on criminal justice policy and practice?
· What are strategies and recommendations you would make for approaching this issue from a criminal justice perspective?
Full Answer Section
Relation to the Course
This film connects to courses related to criminal justice, juvenile delinquency, and potentially law and ethics. It prompts discussion on the effectiveness of the justice system in addressing crimes committed by minors, the psychological development of teenagers, and the potential for rehabilitation versus retribution.
Impact on Criminal Justice
- Sentencing Policies: The film likely highlights the potential flaws in sentencing juveniles to life without parole. It might raise questions about whether such sentences serve justice or hinder rehabilitation.
- Focus on Rehabilitation: The documentary could advocate for a shift in focus towards restorative justice principles when dealing with juvenile offenders. This could include programs aimed at rehabilitation, education, and addressing the root causes of criminal behavior.
- Psychological Considerations: The film might explore the psychological development of adolescents and how it differs from adults. This could raise questions about whether juveniles possess the same level of culpability as adults when committing crimes.
Strategies and Recommendations
- Alternative Sentencing Options: Explore and implement alternative sentencing options for juveniles, focusing on rehabilitation and restorative justice. This could include programs like boot camps, community service, and intensive psychological counseling.
- Psychological Evaluations: Require mandatory psychological evaluations before sentencing juveniles as adults. This would ensure a deeper understanding of the offender's mental state and maturity level.
- Raise the Age of Adulthood: Consider raising the legal age at which a minor can be tried as an adult. This would acknowledge the ongoing brain development in teenagers and potentially reduce the number of juveniles receiving harsh sentences.
- Focus on Rehabilitation Programs: Invest in evidence-based rehabilitation programs specifically designed for young offenders. These programs could address issues like anger management, substance abuse, and emotional regulation.
By exploring these issues, "When Kids Get Life" offers valuable insights for a more nuanced approach to juvenile crime within the criminal justice system.
Sample Answer
Based on the information provided about the film "When Kids Get Life" (PBS), here's an analysis of the film's impression, topic, and its connection to criminal justice:
Impression and Topic
The documentary, focusing on juveniles sentenced to life without parole in Colorado, likely evokes a sense of controversy and raises questions about fairness and rehabilitation. It sheds light on a complex issue within the criminal justice system: the practice of trying and sentencing minors as adults for severe crimes.