The Supreme Court certainly isnt in the news every day, but it performs a very important function. Through intense argument, the Supreme Court arrives at decisions that reflect not just legal influences, but social conditions and changing values as well. Sometimes these cases deal with the U.S. Constitution itself but can also deal with conflicting or controversial state law. Generally, Supreme Court cases go unnoticed by the public, but every so often a landmark case will make headlines. However, each case decided by the Supreme Court determines something called legal precedent for similar future cases to be decided.The great thing about Supreme Court rulings is that you dont have to be a legal expert to understand how decisions and outcomes might affect you. Additionally, though most Supreme Court cases go unnoticed, many of these cases are quite interesting depending on your interests and passions, line of work or field of study. For this paper, you will analyze a Supreme Court ruling that interests or affects you in some way.Lesson OutcomesExplain the importance of the role of the Supreme Court (CLO 1)Explain how and why a case makes it to the Supreme Court (CLO 1, 2).Describe, in detail, a Supreme Court case of your choosing that has been decided in the past two years or will be decided soon (CLO 3, 4, 5).Explain the significance of the selected case (CLO 4, 5).Steps for Completing the TaskStep 1: Background InformationReview the textbook chapter on the court system, view the video below, and view the Oyez link below.Textbook: Chapter 13 on the court system, pages 447 480, specifically 464 473The Lost Art of Democratic Debate (TED Talk)Judicial Decisions: Crash Course Government and PoliticsOyez: Supreme Court casesGoogle search as needed for additional informationStep 2: Select the Paper TopicSelect a Supreme Court case thats either currently being decided or has been decided in the past two years.Step 3: Analyze and EvaluateAfter selecting a case, conduct research to fully understand the facets of the case.Step 4: Write the PaperUsing the background resources provided in addition to researching a Supreme Court case of your choosing, write a two page (minimum) paper (Times New Roman, 12-point font, double spaced) that shows you understand the significance of a case that makes it to the Supreme Court.Below is an example format (this is especially helpful if you have not completed COMP I and II):Introduction Paragraph: Summarizes the purpose of the paper.Paragraphs 2-3: Provide an explanation about the Supreme Courts role and importance in the federal court system as well as how cases make it to the Supreme Court.Paragraph 4: Describe and analyze a selected Supreme Court caseDescribe the case (who/what constitutes either side of the case who is being represented? What are both sides arguing?Describe why the case made it to the Supreme Court.Explain the outcome of the case if available, including the precedent that was set as a result. If the outcome is not available yet, predict which side may win and the precedent that will be set as a result
Supreme Court Case
Full Answer Section
The Supreme Court's Role and How Cases Reach Its Doorstep: The Supreme Court, the highest court in the federal judiciary, plays a critical role in interpreting the U.S. Constitution and ensuring uniformity in federal law. Cases typically reach the Supreme Court through a process called certiorari, where the Court grants or denies review of lower court decisions. Certiorari is usually granted only in cases that raise significant legal questions or involve potential conflicts between federal circuit courts. Gonzalez v. Google LLC: A Case Study in Content Moderation The case of Gonzalez v. Google LLC stems from the 2015 ISIS terrorist attacks in Paris. Nohemi Gonzalez, a U.S. citizen, was killed in the attacks. Her family alleges that Google-owned platforms like YouTube knowingly allowed the spread of ISIS content that contributed to the radicalization of the attackers. The family argues that Google should be held liable for its role in hosting and recommending this harmful content. The Significance of Section 230 and the Current Debate: Section 230 of the CDA provides broad immunity to internet platforms from liability for content posted by users. This provision has been credited with fostering innovation and free speech online. However, critics argue that Section 230 gives platforms like YouTube undue protection, allowing them to shirk responsibility for promoting harmful content like ISIS propaganda. The Potential Outcome and Future Implications: The Supreme Court's decision in Gonzalez v. Google could have a significant impact on the future of online content moderation and free speech on the internet. A narrow ruling in favor of Google might leave Section 230 largely intact. However, a broader ruling against Google could weaken Section 230 protections, potentially forcing platforms to take on more responsibility for user-generated content. This could lead to increased censorship or even a chilling effect on free speech online. Conclusion: The Gonzalez v. Google case highlights the complex tension between online free speech and the need to hold platforms accountable for the content they host. The Supreme Court's upcoming decision will have a ripple effect on how we navigate the vast landscape of information online, with implications for user safety, content moderation practices, and the overall balance between free speech and accountability on the internet.Sample Answer
Net Neutrality and the Future of the Internet: Analyzing the Gonzalez v. Google Case
Introduction:
This paper examines the ongoing legal battle surrounding online content moderation and its implications for free speech on the internet. The specific case under analysis is Gonzalez v. Google LLC, which centers around the controversial Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act (CDA) and its role in protecting internet platforms from liability for content posted by users.