- Are Sonnets 116 and 130, written by Shakespeare, utilizing and focusing more on Humanist concepts, such as Platonism and Neo-Platonism through the semblance of courtly love, or do they mostly promote Individualism through his lyrics as he declares that "If this be error and upon me prov'd, I never writ, nor no man ever lov'd"? Do you think Shakespeare is writing to a lover, or to only a friend? Justify your answer. How do these different philosophies impact the notion of the Renaissance's establishment of a "rebirth" of the culture based on your interpretation?
Sonnets 116 and 130, written by Shakespeare, utilizing and focusing more on Humanist concepts
Full Answer Section
- Sonnet 130:This sonnet, while seemingly more focused on physical appearance, still upholds a core Humanist principle: celebrating the individual. By rejecting conventional notions of beauty ("My mistress' eyes are nothing like the sun"), the speaker asserts his own unique standards and experiences.
- Emotional Intensity:The depth of emotion expressed in both sonnets, particularly Sonnet 116's unwavering commitment, suggests a romantic relationship.
- Courtly Love Themes:Sonnet 116's language ("marriage of true minds") evokes courtly love, a convention often associated with romantic relationships in Renaissance literature.
- Reevaluation of Love:By exploring love beyond physical attraction and societal pressures (Sonnet 130), Shakespeare reflects the humanist emphasis on questioning traditional views.
- Focus on the Individual:Both sonnets showcase the power of individual experience and emotions, aligning with the Renaissance focus on human potential and expression.
- Celebration of Language:The beauty and complexity of the language used in the sonnets themselves exemplify the renewed interest in classical forms and eloquence that characterized the Renaissance.
Sample Answer
Shakespeare's Sonnets 116 and 130 offer a fascinating study in how he blends Humanist concepts with a touch of Individualism. Let's delve deeper:
Humanist Elements:
- Sonnet 116: This sonnet reflects Platonic and Neo-Platonic ideals by portraying a love that transcends physical beauty and endures through time ("Let me not to the marriage of true minds / Admit impediments"). It emphasizes the spiritual and intellectual connection that defines true love, aligning with Humanist ideas of reason and the pursuit of knowledge.