Should the Silent Sam monument be removed

Full Answer Section

      Those who oppose removing the monument argue that it is a historical artifact that should be preserved. They point to the fact that the monument was erected by the United Daughters of the Confederacy in 1913 to honor the Confederate soldiers who fought in the Civil War. They also argue that removing the monument would be an act of censorship and would erase an important part of American history. The solution to this issue is not easy. Ultimately, it is up to the people of North Carolina to decide whether or not to remove the Silent Sam monument. However, it is important to have a thoughtful and respectful discussion about the issue before making a decision. Here are some of the arguments for and against removing the Silent Sam monument: Arguments for removing the monument:

• The monument is a symbol of racism and oppression.
• The monument glorifies the Confederacy and the legacy of slavery.
• The monument is a source of pain and trauma for many African Americans.
• The monument is no longer relevant to modern society.

Arguments against removing the monument:

• The monument is a historical artifact that should be preserved.
• Removing the monument would be an act of censorship.
• Removing the monument would erase an important part of American history.
• Removing the monument would divide the community.

Solutions There are a number of possible solutions to the issue of the Silent Sam monument. Some possible solutions include:

• Remove the monument and place it in a museum or other historical setting. This would allow the monument to be preserved while also removing it from its current location, which is a source of pain and trauma for many African Americans.
• Add plaques to the monument that provide historical context and acknowledge the legacy of racism and oppression in North Carolina. This would help to educate the public about the history of the monument and the Confederacy, while also acknowledging the pain and trauma that the monument causes for many people.
• Leave the monument in place and create a space for public dialogue and discussion about the monument and its meaning. This could involve holding community meetings, installing educational exhibits, or creating public art installations.

Ultimately, the best solution to the issue of the Silent Sam monument is one that is reached through a process of thoughtful and respectful dialogue between all stakeholders.  

Sample Answer

 

Whether or not the Silent Sam monument should be removed is a complex and controversial issue. There are strong arguments on both sides of the debate.

Those who support removing the monument argue that it is a symbol of racism and oppression. They point to the fact that the monument was erected in the early 20th century, during a time when white supremacy was prevalent in the United States. They also argue that the monument continues to glorify the Confederacy and the legacy of slavery.