Preparing a speech on the Department of Homeland Security (DHS)

While preparing a speech on the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Aban runs across a website that has a lot of useful information. The website has numerous articles and links that all discuss the importance of the different functions of the DHS. Being a good speaker, Aban delves into the website to determine the credibility of the information being provided. Aban quickly realizes that the group sponsoring the website is a fringe-militia group that believes no immigrants should be allowed into the United States. While the information Aban is interested has nothing to do with immigration, he wonders if all the information provided on the website has been distorted to support the organization’s basic cause.

  1. Should Aban use the useful information about DHS even though the other information on the website is from an extremist group?
  2. Are all sources on the extremist group’s website automatically suspect because of the groups stated anti-immigration stance?
  3. Is it ethical for Aban to use any of the information from this website?
  4. If Aban was a friend of yours and he showed you the website, how would you tell him to proceed?

find the cost of your paper

Sample Answer

 

 

Whether or not Aban should use the useful information about DHS from the website sponsored by a fringe-militia group is a complex question. There are a number of factors to consider, including:

  • The credibility of the information itself. Is the information accurate and up-to-date? Is it based on reliable sources?
  • The purpose of Aban’s speech. Is he simply trying to inform his audience about DHS, or is he trying to promote a particular agenda?
  • The potential impact of using the information. Could using the information be seen as endorsing the views of the extremist group?

Full Answer Section

 

 

 

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to use the information is up to Aban. However, he should carefully consider all of the factors involved before making a decision.

Are all sources on the extremist group’s website automatically suspect because of the groups stated anti-immigration stance?

Not necessarily. It is possible that the extremist group has provided accurate information about DHS on their website, even though they have other extreme views. However, it is important to be critical of any information that comes from a source that has a known bias.

Is it ethical for Aban to use any of the information from this website?

Whether or not it is ethical for Aban to use any of the information from this website is a matter of opinion. Some people believe that it is never ethical to use information from a source that has extreme views. Others believe that it is acceptable to use information from an extremist group as long as the information is accurate and up-to-date.

How would I tell Aban to proceed?

If Aban were a friend of mine and he showed me the website, I would tell him to carefully consider all of the factors involved before deciding whether or not to use the information. I would also encourage him to be transparent with his audience about the source of the information.

Here are some specific things that Aban could do:

  • He could cross-reference the information on the website with information from other, more credible sources.
  • He could quote or cite the information from the website, but also include information about the website’s sponsor and the group’s stated anti-immigration stance.
  • He could explain to his audience why he is choosing to use information from this particular source.

By taking these steps, Aban can help to ensure that his audience is aware of the potential bias of the information and can make their own judgments about its credibility.

 

This question has been answered.

Get Answer