A colleague is not sure whether to use self-report, direct observation, or available records to operationally define the degree of sensitivity of nursing home staff to the needs of residents. In your own words, describe the advantages and disadvantages of each approach, and, provide a detailed description in regard to which approach may be the best option and why.
Operational Definitions
Full Answer Section
- Can be used to collect data from a large number of people quickly and easily.
Disadvantages:
- Susceptible to biases. Self-report measures can be susceptible to a variety of biases, such as social desirability bias, recall bias, and response bias.
- Requires participants to be able to accurately and reliably report on their own thoughts, feelings, and behaviors.
- May not be suitable for all participants. For example, young children or people with cognitive impairments may not be able to accurately complete self-report measures.
Direct observation
Advantages:
- Less susceptible to biases than self-report. Direct observation is less susceptible to biases because it does not rely on participants to report on their own thoughts, feelings, and behaviors.
- Can provide objective data on observable behaviors. Direct observation can provide objective data on observable behaviors, such as frequency, duration, and intensity.
- Can be used to collect data on behaviors that participants may be unaware of or unwilling to report.
Disadvantages:
- Can be time-consuming and expensive to conduct. Direct observation often requires trained observers to collect data over an extended period of time.
- May be disruptive to the participants' natural behavior. Observers may be detected by the participants, which could alter their behavior.
- May not be feasible in all settings. Direct observation is not always feasible in certain settings, such as clinical settings or private homes.
Overall, both self-report and direct observation have their own advantages and disadvantages. The best method to use will depend on the specific research question and the characteristics of the participants.
Here is a table that summarizes the key advantages and disadvantages of self-report and direct observation:
Method | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|
Self-report | * Relatively inexpensive and easy to administer * Can access internal states and processes * Can be used to collect data from a large number of people quickly and easily | * Susceptible to biases * Requires participants to be able to accurately and reliably report on their own thoughts, feelings, and behaviors * May not be suitable for all participants |
Direct observation | * Less susceptible to biases than self-report * Can provide objective data on observable behaviors * Can be used to collect data on behaviors that participants may be unaware of or unwilling to report | * Can be time-consuming and expensive to conduct * May be disruptive to the participants' natural behavior * May not be feasible in all settings |
Researchers often use a combination of self-report and direct observation methods to get a more complete picture of a particular phenomenon. For example, a researcher might use a self-report questionnaire to assess a participant's anxiety levels, and then use direct observation to assess their anxious behaviors during a public speaking task.
Sample Answer
Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Self-Report and Direct Observation
Self-report
Advantages:
- Relatively inexpensive and easy to administer. Self-report measures can be administered in a variety of ways, including paper-and-pencil questionnaires, online surveys, and interviews.
- Can access internal states and processes. Self-report measures are the only way to directly measure internal states and processes, such as thoughts, feelings, motivations, and intentions.