- Analyze Walt’s process of adapting to cultural diversity (Ch. 4). Identify the difference between Walt’s culture and the Hmong people.
- Looking closely at Walt’s communications style, how would you describe his verbal communication skills versus of Thao and Sue? What are the meanings and purposes Walt attaches to talk?
- How does Walt view friendship different than Thao and Sue? What strategies are different between them in initiating and maintaining friendships?
Movie Analysis
Full Answer Section
- Challenges and Frustration: However, there are moments of frustration when communication barriers arise due to language and cultural differences. For example, the concept of "face" might be unfamiliar to Walt, leading to misunderstandings.
- Cultural Relativism: As the chapter progresses, Walt shows signs of developing cultural relativism. He tries to see things from the Hmong perspective and understand their experiences within their cultural context.
- Communication Style: The Hmong culture may emphasize indirect communication and respecting elders, while Walt might be more direct and assertive.
- Family Values: The Hmong culture likely prioritizes strong family bonds and collectivism, whereas Walt might come from a more individualistic culture.
- Religious Beliefs: The Hmong may have traditional religious practices that differ from Walt's belief system.
- Communication Styles:
- Walt: Walt's communication style is likely direct and assertive. He might value clarity and efficiency in conversation.
- Thao and Sue: Thao and Sue might be more indirect and respectful in their communication, especially towards elders. They might prioritize maintaining social harmony and avoiding conflict.
- Walt's View of Talk: For Walt, talk might be a tool for information exchange, problem-solving, and asserting his opinions.
- Thao and Sue's View of Talk: For Thao and Sue, talk might serve a more nuanced purpose. It could be used for building relationships, expressing respect, and navigating cultural expectations.
- Friendship Dynamics:
- Walt: Walt might initiate friendships based on shared interests or activities. He might be more comfortable with direct expressions of affection or camaraderie.
- Thao and Sue: Thao and Sue might prioritize building trust and understanding before initiating a friendship. They might value more subtle expressions of care and respect within the friendship.
- Walt: Walt might be more likely to directly ask someone to be friends or participate in an activity.
- Thao and Sue: Thao and Sue might spend more time getting to know someone through shared experiences or indirect gestures of support before considering them a friend.
Sample Answer
Walt's Journey with Cultural Diversity (Chapter 4 of The Joy Luck Club)
1. Walt's Adaptation and Cultural Differences:
-
Limited Understanding: Walt initially approaches the Hmong culture with a sense of curiosity but limited understanding. He relies on stereotypes and generalizations, referring to them as "exotic" and unfamiliar with their customs.
-
Gradual Acceptance: Through exposure to the Hmong traditions and stories shared by the mothers, Walt starts to appreciate their cultural richness. He becomes more accepting and respectful of their beliefs and practices.