Q10
Read: http://digital-deadly-sins.theguardian.com/#/Envy/19 “I Fake It On Facebook”
Answer the following questions:
• How do people construct an identity on social media? Provide examples. Is selective self-presentation occurring?
• Is it unethical to create a different version of yourself online? When could it be considered unethical?
Full Answer Section
- Using idealized filters and editing: Photos and videos are often edited to enhance appearance and portray a more glamorous image. (Example: Using filters that smooth skin or enhance features, cropping out imperfections)
This selective self-presentation is undeniable. Social media platforms function as a highlight reel, showcasing the best versions of ourselves.
Is it Unethical?
The ethics of creating a different version of yourself online depend on context and intent. Here's a breakdown:
- Generally Acceptable: Curating a positive online image is not inherently unethical. People want to portray themselves favorably, and social media provides a platform for self-expression.
- Unethical Practices: Deception becomes an issue when the online persona significantly diverges from reality, particularly:
- Misrepresenting reality: Creating a facade of wealth, success, or relationships that don't exist is misleading.
- Harming others: Online bragging or negativity intended to belittle others is unethical.
- Negative impact on self-esteem: Obsessively comparing oneself to curated online lives can lead to anxiety and depression.
Finding Balance
Social media can be a valuable tool for connection and self-expression. However, it's important to maintain a healthy balance:
- Be mindful of curation: Acknowledge that most online profiles are idealized versions of reality.
- Focus on authenticity: Share a mix of experiences, positive and negative, to portray a more genuine image.
- Prioritize real connections: Don't let social media comparisons overshadow real-life interactions.
By being mindful of selective self-presentation and its potential pitfalls, we can use social media to create a positive and authentic online presence.
Sample Answer
The Guardian article "I Fake It on Facebook" delves into the phenomenon of selective self-presentation on social media. People construct their online identity through a carefully curated selection of moments, achievements, and experiences. This curation often involves:
- Highlighting positive aspects: Users showcase vacations, achievements, and happy moments, crafting a narrative of a successful and fulfilling life. (Example: Posting pictures from an exotic trip, showcasing promotions or awards received)
- Omitting negativity: Struggles, failures, and vulnerabilities are rarely shared, creating an illusion of a perfect life. (Example: Not mentioning job frustrations, relationship issues, or financial difficulties)