Events that can easily occur in academic research settings

The following vignette describe events that can easily occur in academic research settings. First, identify the ethical violations committed in the vignettes. Then, identify a plan that could prevent such violations before research projects have even begun.
Dr. Gabriel has a very active research lab at her university. She regularly submits grants, and her graduate students publish papers frequently. The following situations develop in Dr. Gabriel’s lab:

Dr. Gabriel is in the process of writing a large grant proposal and locates a literature review and summary of preliminary findings written and presented in a recent lab meeting by Seara, a graduate student working in her lab. Dr. Gabriel cuts and pastes the text of this document into the grant.

Identify the ethical violations committed in the vignette.

Identify a plan that could prevent such violations before research projects have even begun.

Sample Answer

Dr. Gabriel’s actions in the vignette constitute a number of ethical violations, including:

Plagiarism: Dr. Gabriel copied Seara’s work without attribution, which is plagiarism. Plagiarism is a serious ethical violation because it undermines the integrity of scholarly research.
Falsification of data: Dr. Gabriel presented Seara’s work as her own, which can be seen as a form of falsification of data. Falsification of data is another serious ethical violation because it undermines the credibility of research findings.

Full Answer Section

Abuse of power: Dr. Gabriel is in a position of power over Seara, her graduate student. She used this power to take advantage of Seara’s work without her permission. Abuse of power is an ethical violation because it creates an unfair and exploitative relationship.

Plan to prevent such violations before research projects have even begun

A number of things can be done to prevent the types of ethical violations committed by Dr. Gabriel before research projects have even begun. These include:

Education: It is important to educate researchers about the ethical principles that govern research conduct. This education should be provided to both faculty and students.
Supervision: Faculty should provide close supervision to their students and trainees. This supervision should include training on ethical research conduct and monitoring of students’ work.
Research integrity policies: Institutions should have clear and comprehensive research integrity policies in place. These policies should outline the ethical principles that govern research conduct and the consequences for violating these principles.
Whistleblowing policies: Institutions should have whistleblowing policies in place that encourage researchers to report suspected ethical violations. These policies should protect whistleblowers from retaliation.

In addition to these general measures, there are a number of specific things that Dr. Gabriel could have done to prevent the ethical violations in the vignette. For example, she could have:

Asked Seara’s permission to use her work in the grant proposal.
Cited Seara’s work in the grant proposal.
Collaborated with Seara on the grant proposal.

It is important to note that there is no single solution that will completely eliminate the risk of ethical violations in academic research. However, by taking the steps outlined above, institutions and researchers can reduce the risk of these violations and create a more ethical research environment.

This question has been answered.

Get Answer

No More Worries!

Paper Formatting

No Lateness!

Our Guarantees