Selecting EBP Model for your EBP Question
Select one of the common EBP models that you think it best fits your PICOT question and then explain/justify your selection considering the following:
The clarity and conciseness of the model’s concepts and organization
The diagrammatic representation of the model and the ability to assimilate the concepts and organizes the step of the desired EBP changes
The comprehensiveness of the model from the beginning stages to implementation and evaluation of outcomes
The easiness of the use when concepts are applied to direct EBP changes and practice issues in clinical settings
The flexibility of the model to be applied to various populations of patients, EBP projects, initiatives, and programs
The use and popularity of the model in the published literature
This assignment should be no more than 2-3 pages (not including the title or references pages).
Common EBP Models:
The Stetler Model of Evidence-Based Practice
The Iowa Model of Evidence-Based Practice to promote quality care
The Model for Evidence-Based Practice Change
The Advancing Research and Clinical practice through close Collaboration (ARCC) model for implementation and sustainability of EBP
The Promoting Action on Research Implementation in Health Services (PARIHS) framework
The Clinical Scholar model
The Johns Hopkins Nursing Evidence-Based Practice model
The ACE Star Model of Knowledge Transformation
EBP Model for your EBP
Full Answer Section
Justification for Selecting the JHNEBP Model:
-
Clarity and Conciseness of Concepts and Organization:
- The JHNEBP model is structured around a clear and concise three-phase process: PET (Practice question, Evidence, Translation). This streamlined approach makes it easy to understand and follow.
- It provides practical tools and resources, such as the evidence appraisal tools and evidence rating scales, which simplify the process of evaluating evidence.
- The model breaks down a complex process into easily digestible steps.
-
Diagrammatic Representation and Assimilation:
- The JHNEBP model is typically represented with a clear flow diagram that visually outlines the PET process.
- This diagrammatic representation facilitates the assimilation of concepts and helps practitioners visualize the steps involved in implementing EBP changes.
- The visual layout helps to create a logical flow for the EBP project.
-
Comprehensiveness from Beginning to Evaluation:
- The JHNEBP model provides comprehensive guidance from the initial step of formulating a practice question to the final stage of evaluating outcomes.
- It emphasizes the importance of evidence appraisal, synthesis, and translation into practice, ensuring a thorough and rigorous approach.
- The model also stresses the importance of dissemination of the results.
-
Easiness of Use in Clinical Settings:
- The JHNEBP model is designed to be user-friendly and practical for use in clinical settings.
- The tools and resources provided, such as the evidence appraisal guides and implementation planning templates, simplify the EBP process for busy clinicians.
- The model is very approachable.
-
Flexibility for Various Populations and Projects:
- The JHNEBP model is highly flexible and can be applied to a wide range of patient populations, EBP projects, initiatives, and programs.
- Its core principles and processes are adaptable to various clinical settings and healthcare disciplines.
- The model can handle many different types of evidence.
-
Use and Popularity in Published Literature:
- The JHNEBP model is widely recognized and used in the nursing literature.
- Numerous studies and publications have demonstrated its effectiveness in guiding EBP implementation.
- It is a well respected model.
Application to the PICOT Question:
- Practice Question (P): The JHNEBP model's emphasis on formulating a clear and focused practice question aligns perfectly with the PICOT format.
- Evidence (E): The model provides a systematic approach to searching, appraising, and synthesizing evidence related to standardized pain assessment tools.
- Translation (T): The model guides the implementation of the chosen pain assessment tool into clinical practice, considering factors such as staff training, resource availability, and patient education.
- The evaluation portion of the model, will allow for the data collection of the patient pain scores and opioid consumption to assess the effectiveness of the new standardized pain assessment tool.
In conclusion, the JHNEBP model's clarity, comprehensiveness, ease of use, and flexibility make it an excellent choice for guiding the implementation of my PICOT question. It provides a structured and practical framework for translating evidence into practice and improving patient outcomes
Sample Answer
For this assignment, I would select the Johns Hopkins Nursing Evidence-Based Practice (JHNEBP) model as the most suitable for guiding the implementation of my PICOT question. Here's a justification based on the provided criteria:
PICOT Question (Example - Replace with your Actual PICOT):
"In adult patients (P) undergoing post-operative pain management (I), how does the implementation of a standardized pain assessment tool (C) compared to the current pain assessment method (O) affect patient-reported pain scores and opioid consumption (O) within the first 48 hours post-surgery?"