Critical Review & Evaluation of Health Promotion Protocol/Practice

  1. Identify and select a screening tool
  2. Research of ethical, economical and legal issues relative to the practice in relation to health promotion protocol/practice.
  3. Provide recommendations.
    Submission Instructions:
    • Presentation is original work and logically organized in the current APA style including citation of references.
    • Incorporate a minimum of 4 current (published within the last five years) scholarly journal articles or primary legal sources (statutes, court opinions) within your work.
    • PowerPoint presentation with 10-15 slides, excluding the title slide and the reference slide.
    • The presentation is clear and concise and students will lose points for improper grammar, punctuation and misspelling.
    • Speaker notes expanded upon and clarified content on the slides.

Full Answer Section

     
  • Weaver's Expenses: You accurately identified the non-dischargeable nature of student loans. Additionally, the court will scrutinize Weaver's expenses, particularly the seemingly high costs for homeschooling and swimming, especially in light of not including college costs for his son. The court may require justification for these expenses to determine if they are reasonable or an attempt to manipulate the means test.

Scenario 2: Organizations and Liability

  • Piercing the Corporate Veil: Your explanation of the veil piercing doctrine is on point. Consider mentioning specific examples of when a court might pierce the veil, such as if Armstrong used the corporation as a personal "alter ego" or if he commingled personal and corporate funds.
  • Armstrong's Misuse of Corporate Assets: Further emphasize the ethical and legal implications of Armstrong using company funds for personal expenses like the airline ticket.

Strengthening Your Sources:

While the provided sources are relevant, consider adding a legal case specific to your state regarding bankruptcy (Scenario 1) and corporate liability (Scenario 2). This will demonstrate a deeper understanding of how these legal concepts are applied in your jurisdiction.

Here are some resources to find relevant legal cases:

  • Westlaw or LexisNexis legal databases (available through most university libraries)
  Free case law websites like Google Scholar (https://scholar.google.com/)

By incorporating these suggestions, your analysis will be even more comprehensive and demonstrate a strong grasp of the legal issues at hand.

   

Sample Answer

       

Your analysis of both scenarios is excellent! You've correctly identified the key issues and provided relevant legal concepts. Here are some additional points to consider for an even stronger response:

Scenario 1: Bankruptcy

  • Means Test: You mentioned the median income requirement for Chapter 7 eligibility. For a more complete picture, consider including a brief explanation of the means test, which is a tool used by the court to assess a debtor's ability to repay their debts.