Criminal evidence

Questions

  1. What types of evidence are included in the terms “writing” and “recording” in the FRE?
  2. What are the various uses of photographic and recorded evidence?
  3. What is the second rule of admissibility of photographic and recorded evidence?
  4. Who can be called as a witness to authenticate a photograph or recording?
  5. What are the methods used to notify a witness to appear in court?
  6. Explain what a law enforcement witness should do while testifying with respect to objections?

Full Answer Section

       

1. Types of Evidence in "Writing" and "Recording"

The Federal Rules of Evidence (FRE) define "writing" and "recording" broadly to include any form of communication that can be perceived, reproduced, or transmitted. This includes:

  • Printed materials: Books, newspapers, letters, contracts, etc.
  • Electronic records: Emails, text messages, social media posts, digital photographs, videos, etc.
  • Handwritten documents: Notes, letters, diaries, etc.
  • Audio recordings: Phone calls, interviews, meetings, etc.
  • Video recordings: Surveillance footage, interviews, events, etc.

4. Uses of Photographic and Recorded Evidence

Photographic and recorded evidence can be used for various purposes in legal proceedings, including:

  • Proving a fact: Demonstrating the existence or non-existence of something.
  • Illustrating testimony: Helping a witness explain their observations or experiences.
  • Impeaching a witness: Contradicting a witness's testimony or demonstrating inconsistencies.
  • Identifying individuals or objects: Providing visual evidence to identify people or things involved in a case.
  • Documenting the scene: Preserving a record of a crime scene or other relevant location.

7. Second Rule of Admissibility of Photographic and Recorded Evidence

The second rule of admissibility for photographic and recorded evidence requires that the evidence be relevant to the case and that its probative value outweighs any potential prejudice. This means that the evidence must be relevant to the issues being tried and must not be unfairly prejudicial to the opposing party.

8. Witnesses to Authenticate Photographs or Recordings

The following individuals can typically be called as witnesses to authenticate a photograph or recording:

  • The person who took the photograph or made the recording.
  • Someone who was present when the photograph or recording was made and can attest to its authenticity.
  • An expert witness who can verify the authenticity of the photograph or recording through technical analysis.

1. Notifying a Witness to Appear in Court

There are several methods used to notify a witness to appear in court, including:

  • Subpoena: A legal document that orders a person to appear in court to testify.
  • Written notice: A letter or other written communication informing the witness of the court date and time.
  • Personal service: A law enforcement officer delivering the notice directly to the witness.

4. Conduct of a Law Enforcement Witness During Testimony

While testifying, a law enforcement witness should:

  • Answer questions truthfully and accurately.
  • Avoid speculating or making assumptions.
  • Stick to the facts of the case.
  • Be respectful of the court and opposing counsel.
  • Follow the instructions of the presiding judge.
  • Avoid making personal comments or opinions.
  • Be prepared to respond to objections and cross-examination.

It is important for law enforcement witnesses to understand the rules of evidence and the importance of providing clear and concise testimony.

Sample Answer