Cases that address the definition of probable cause and their impact on policing

Full Answer Section

    Supreme Court Cases and Impact on Policing: Numerous Supreme Court cases have refined the definition of probable cause and its application in policing, influencing police practices and impacting the balance between public safety and individual rights. Here are some key examples:

• Illinois v. Gates (1983): Established the "totality of the circumstances" test, which allows consideration of seemingly weak pieces of evidence that, when combined, form probable cause. This broadened the scope for finding probable cause.
• Spinelli v. United States (1969): Established the "two-pronged test" for informant tips, requiring both sufficient basis for the informant's knowledge and corroborating details to support the information. This case limited the use of unreliable informant tips.
• Texas v. Brown (2014): Clarified that an officer's mistaken belief in the validity of a warrant cannot justify a search, even if based on good faith reliance. This ruling emphasized the importance of proper warrant procedures.

Stale Information and United States v. Leon (1984): While Leon did state that five-month-old information may be too "stale" for probable cause, it also emphasized that staleness is case-specific. Situations where older information could still be considered fresh include:

• Continuing crimes: For ongoing criminal activity like drug trafficking, even older information might be valid if it demonstrates a pattern of ongoing criminal behavior.
• Highly reliable source: Information from a proven, highly reliable source can maintain its value even after some time.
• Corroborating evidence: If subsequent events or independent confirmation bolster the older information, it strengthens its relevance for establishing probable cause.

In conclusion: Probable cause is a dynamic concept evolving through case law, affecting various police practices. While Leon highlights the potential staleness of information, it also reminds us to consider the specific circumstances. Evaluating factors like the nature of the crime, source reliability, and corroborating evidence can help determine whether older information retains its value for establishing probable cause. Maintaining this balance between investigative needs and individual rights is crucial for effective and constitutional policing.  

Sample Answer

   

Probable Cause: Definition and Case Law Impact on Policing

Defining Probable Cause:

Probable cause, a cornerstone of the Fourth Amendment, is the reasonable belief that a person has committed a crime or that evidence of a crime is present in a specific location. The standard is lower than "beyond a reasonable doubt" required for conviction, but greater than a mere suspicion or hunch. Police officers need probable cause to justify:

• Warrants for arrest or search: A neutral judge reviews an officer's affidavit explaining the basis for probable cause before issuing a warrant.
• Searches and seizures without a warrant: In certain exigent circumstances (e.g., hot pursuit, risk of destruction of evidence), officers can conduct warrantless searches if they have probable cause.