Dynamic pricing is a collection of pricing strategies used by firms and organizations to enhance profits. You will begin by exploring pricing techniques that operate in the market in real-time. Then you will explore how auctions are employed in the search to find the value of goods and services.
The following is a great resource for additional research to complete your assignment, see Chapters 11 and 12.
For your convenience, the following resource is provided by the Strayer Library at no cost. Links to the online library resources are also available in Canvas via the Course Information page. You may also search by title in the online Strayer Library.
McAfee, R. P. (2009). Competitive Solutions: The Strategist's Toolkit. Princeton University Press.
Instructions
Write a 5-7 page paper in which you:
Compare and contrast surge versus congestion pricing. Provide a specific example of each currently in use.
There are many types of auctions, each with strengths and weaknesses in uncovering the real price/value of an item. Compare and contrast how each of the following uncovers value and provide a specific example of how each uncovers value:
The English auction and the Dutch auction.
The sealed-bid first-price auction and the Vickery Auction.
Auctions are widely used. Analyze an actual auction employed by each of the following:
A state or federal government or an agency of a state or federal government.
A for-profit business.
For each, explain what type of auction is employed and how the auction solves the problem of finding the best price for the good or service.
Read the Letter from Senator Warren to Fed on Wells Fargo FHC StatusLinks to an external site.[PDF].
Explain how an auction to sell the Wells Fargo consumer-facing banking division might be used to determine the value of the division.
Include a recommendation on what type of auction might be used.
Full Answer Section
Surge vs. Congestion Pricing:
Surge pricing is a dynamic pricing strategy that involves raising prices temporarily during periods of high demand. This strategy is commonly used by companies like Uber and Lyft to adjust their fares based on traffic conditions and ride availability. During peak hours or in areas with limited car availability, surge pricing can significantly increase fares, incentivizing drivers to work and ensuring passenger demand is met.
Congestion pricing, on the other hand, is a broader strategy that aims to manage traffic flow by dynamically adjusting prices for specific resources or services. This can be implemented through tolls on highways, parking fees in busy areas, or even variable pricing for public transportation. The goal is to discourage unnecessary use of resources during peak times, thereby reducing congestion and improving overall efficiency.
Example of Surge Pricing: Uber's dynamic pricing algorithm automatically increases fares when demand for rides exceeds supply. During rush hour or on rainy days, Uber users may see significantly higher prices compared to off-peak hours. This incentivizes more drivers to log in and service the increased demand, while also ensuring Uber maximizes its revenue during peak periods.
Example of Congestion Pricing: London's congestion charge is a classic example of congestion pricing. Implemented in 2003, the scheme requires drivers to pay a daily fee to enter central London during peak hours. This has significantly reduced traffic congestion within the city, improving air quality and public transportation efficiency.
Auction Types and Value Uncovering:
- English Auction vs. Dutch Auction:
- English Auction: This is a common auction format where bidders compete openly, gradually raising their bids until only one bidder remains. The highest bid wins the item. This format is good at uncovering the maximum price a buyer is willing to pay.
- Dutch Auction: In this format, the auctioneer starts with a high asking price and gradually lowers it until a bidder accepts the price. This format is good for selling a large quantity of identical items quickly.
Example: An art auction typically follows the English auction format, where bidders compete openly until the highest bid wins the artwork. This format helps determine the true market value of the artwork based on the competing bids.
- Sealed-Bid First-Price Auction vs. Vickrey Auction:
- Sealed-Bid First-Price Auction: Bidders submit their bids in private, and the highest bidder wins the item at their bid price. This can lead to strategic bidding, where bidders underestimate their true value to avoid overpaying.
- Vickrey Auction: Similar to the sealed-bid first-price auction, bids are submitted in private. However, the winner pays the second-highest bid price, not their own. This incentivizes bidders to be truthful about their valuations.
Example: Government procurement contracts often use sealed-bid auctions, such as the Vickrey auction. This format encourages accurate bids from bidders while ensuring the government obtains the best price for the contract.
Real-World Application of Auctions:
- Government Auctions:
The US government frequently uses auctions to sell surplus property, such as land, vehicles, and equipment. These auctions typically follow the sealed-bid first-price format, allowing the government to quickly dispose of assets and maximize revenue.
- Business Auctions:
Many businesses utilize auctions for various purposes, including liquidating inventory, selling new products, and raising capital. eBay is a well-known example of a business that uses both English and Dutch auctions to facilitate online transactions. Additionally, investment banks often use auctions to sell securities and other financial instruments.
Wells Fargo Consumer-Facing Banking Division Auction:
Senator Elizabeth Warren has proposed selling the consumer-facing banking division of Wells Fargo through a public auction. This action aims to address the bank's history of fraudulent activities and restore public trust.
Recommended Auction Type:
An open outcry auction, similar to the English auction format, could be suitable for this scenario. This would allow for transparent bidding and ensure the highest possible price is achieved for the division. Bidders would compete openly, gradually raising their bids until only one bidder remains. This format would ensure the highest possible price for the division while also providing transparency and accountability in the sale process.
Conclusion:
Dynamic pricing and auctions are powerful tools that businesses and governments can utilize to maximize their profitability and achieve specific objectives. Understanding the different types of pricing strategies and auction formats allows for informed decision-making and effective implementation of these strategies in real-world
Sample Answer
Dynamic Pricing: Strategies for Enhancing Profitability
Introduction:
In today's dynamic and competitive market environment, businesses are constantly searching for effective strategies to maximize their profitability. One such strategy is dynamic pricing, a collection of pricing techniques that adjust prices in real-time based on factors such as demand, supply, competitor pricing, and other market conditions. This paper will explore various aspects of dynamic pricing, including surge pricing, congestion pricing, different types of auctions, and their application in real-world scenarios.