- Think about the value chain for a carton of eggs that is sold in the grocery store.
(Start from the chicken and continue to the point of sale in the grocery store.) List as many steps in the value chain as you can imagine. At what points in the value chain does waste most likely occur? - In this chapter, the eight wastes of traditional operations were discussed.
Which types of waste are in the value chain that you identified in Question 1? - Answer the following questions from the standpoint of Cal-Maine Foods, Inc., and its egg farms:
a. What costs will be incurred to individually stamp each egg?
b. What impact on revenue would the process of individually stamping each egg have?
C. What wastes in the value chain occur at Cal-Maine Foods (and its egg farms)? - Now answer the following questions from the standpoint of Walmart
a. What costs might decrease as a result of purchasing eggs that are stamped individually with grade, size, traceability code, and freshness date information?
B. What costs might increase as a result of purchasing individually stamped eggs?
C. What wastes in the value chain occur at Walmart? - Who should bear the cost of the individual egg-stamping operations: Cal-Maine Foods, Walmart, or the consumer?
Because of the tremendous amount of waste involved with the current system of discarding entire cartons, should individual egg stamping be mandated by the government? Why or why not?
Cal-Maine Foods, Inc.,
Full Answer Section
- Distribution and transportation: Packed cartons are transported in refrigerated trucks to distribution centers and then to grocery stores.
- Storage and display: Eggs are stored in refrigerated shelves at the grocery store until purchased.
Potential Waste Points:
- Chick culling: Male chicks, unwanted for egg production, may be culled early, generating ethical concerns and resource waste.
- Cracked or broken eggs: During handling, sorting, and transport, eggs may crack and become unusable.
- Spoilage: Improper storage temperatures or exceeding shelf life can lead to spoilage and food waste.
- Oversupply and demand fluctuations: Mismatching production with market demand can result in excess eggs that may need to be discounted or discarded.
- Packaging waste: Cardboard cartons and plastic fillers contribute to material waste after consumer use.
- Transportation inefficiencies: Unoptimized routes or vehicles can result in unnecessary fuel consumption and emissions.
Types of Waste from Lean Principles:
- Overproduction: Producing more eggs than market demand, leading to oversupply and potential spoilage.
- Waiting: Idle time for hens, trucks, or workers due to inefficient scheduling or processing delays.
- Transportation: Unnecessary movement of eggs due to inefficient distribution networks or improper routing.
- Motion: Excessive handling of eggs during sorting, packaging, and transport, increasing risk of breakage.
- Defects: Cracked or broken eggs due to improper handling or inadequate packaging.
- Inventory: Excessive stock of eggs at any stage, increasing storage costs and risk of spoilage.
- Processing: Inefficient processes like manual egg stamping that add unnecessary time and cost.
- Non-utilized talent: Underutilizing the skills and knowledge of workers in the process.
Cost of Individual Egg Stamping:
For Cal-Maine Foods, stamping each egg individually would create significant financial and operational challenges:
- Increased Labor Costs: Implementing manual stamping requires additional resources and employee training, resulting in higher labor costs.
- Reduced Efficiency: Stamping slows down the processing line, affecting overall production speed and throughput.
- Ink and Equipment Costs: Purchasing and maintaining stamping equipment and ink cartridges would represent additional expenses.
- Logistics and Integration: Integrating stamping into existing lines might require equipment modifications and adjustments, leading to further investments.
- Impact on Egg Quality: Additional handling for stamping could increase the risk of egg breakage and reduce overall quality.
Instead of individual stamping, Cal-Maine Foods and other egg producers typically rely on:
- Batch coding: Cartons are stamped with batch codes or production dates for traceability and quality control purposes.
- Grade markings: Different grades of eggs are differentiated through symbols or color coding on the carton itself.
- Producer identification: Cartons often display the farm or brand information, eliminating the need for individual egg stamping.
Individual egg stamping might offer limited benefits like enhanced traceability, but the associated costs and operational drawbacks often outweigh any potential advantages. Cal-Maine Foods and other egg producers focus on optimizing their value chain by minimizing waste, improving efficiency, and delivering quality products to consumers at competitive prices.
Sample Answer
Egg Carton Value Chain: From Hen to Grocery Shelf
Steps in the Value Chain:
- Breeding and hatching: Hens are bred and eggs are hatched in controlled environments.
- Chick rearing: Chicks are raised in temperature-controlled facilities with specific feed and light cycles.
- Laying hens: Mature hens are housed in various systems (cages, free-range, barn) and eggs are collected daily.
- Egg grading and sorting: Eggs are graded for size, quality, and cleanliness. Cracks, deformities, and blood spots are discarded.
- Washing and sanitizing: Eggs are washed and sanitized to remove bacteria and dirt.
- Packaging: Eggs are packaged in cartons with cushioning materials and branding.