Budget variance

  1. Explain what a budget variance is. Is it good to have a budget variance? How can budget variances be avoided?
  2. Explain what a standard cost system is and the advantages and disadvantages of using them for budgeting.
  3. Incremental analysis is used to help companies make decisions involving a choice among alternative courses of action. People use incremental analysis in their personal decision-making as well. Provide a hypothetical example from your personal life of how you might use incremental analysis in making a decision.
  4. In incremental analysis, only relevant costs are considered when making a decision among alternatives. Explain what relevant costs are. Would these include only variable costs? Explain
  5. Explain the difference between centralized and decentralized operations. Describe the advantages and disadvantages of both.
  6. Describe how the responsibilities of a manager might differ between a cost center, a profit center, and an investment center. How do the reports differ for each?
  7. Explain the capital budgeting process and describe the available methods of evaluating alternative investments. Explain in your own words what is meant by the time value of money and why some of the methods consider it and others do not. Give an example of a method that considers it and one that does not.
  8. Capital investment decisions require consideration of both quantitative and qualitative factors. Please give some examples of quantitative considerations, and explain whether you think qualitative factors are equally important as quantitative factors. Support your reasoning.

Full Answer Section

     
  • Avoiding Budget Variances: It's challenging to completely eliminate variances. However, practices like:

    • Setting realistic budgets based on historical data and market trends.
    • Regularly monitoring and analyzing variances to identify trends and take corrective actions.
    • Implementing flexible budgeting that adjusts to changing conditions.
  1. Standard Cost System: A standard cost system assigns predetermined costs to products or services. This allows for variance analysis to identify spending deviations.
  • Advantages:

    • Improved cost control and efficiency tracking.
    • Early identification of potential problems.
    • Provides a benchmark for performance evaluation.
  • Disadvantages:

    • Setting unrealistic standards can be demotivating.
    • Requires ongoing maintenance and updates.
    • Can be complex and time-consuming to implement.
  1. Incremental Analysis in Personal Life: Imagine you're deciding between a weekend getaway at a nearby cabin (Option A) costing $200 or a trip to a farther location (Option B) costing $500, but with included meals ($200 value).
  • Incremental analysis focuses on the additional cost of Option B ($500) compared to Option A ($200). In this case, the relevant cost is the incremental cost of $300 (difference between options) to consider if the additional travel and meals are worth it for you.
  1. Relevant Costs: In incremental analysis, relevant costs are the future costs that differ between alternatives. They can be variable (change with production volume) or fixed (remain constant) but only if they differ between the options being considered.
  • Not all variable costs might be relevant. In the travel example, your existing car insurance (fixed cost) wouldn't be a relevant cost as it's incurred regardless of the chosen trip.
  1. Centralized vs. Decentralized Operations:
  • Centralized: Decision-making authority rests with top management, leading to:

    • Advantages: Consistency in policies and procedures, economies of scale in purchasing.
    • Disadvantages: Slow decision-making, lack of employee engagement.
  • Decentralized: Decision-making power is delegated to lower levels, resulting in:

    • Advantages: Faster response to market changes, increased employee motivation.
    • Disadvantages: Potential for inconsistencies, difficulty achieving economies of scale.
  1. Managerial Responsibilities by Cost Center, Profit Center, and Investment Center:
  • Cost Center: Focuses on controlling costs (e.g., a human resources department). Managers are evaluated on meeting budget targets for expenses. Reports typically focus on cost variances.
  • Profit Center: Generates revenue and incurs costs (e.g., a retail store). Managers are evaluated on profitability (revenue minus costs). Reports include income statements and cost variances.
  • Investment Center: Makes investment decisions and is evaluated on return on investment (ROI). Reports include income statements, balance sheets, and ROI metrics.
  1. Capital Budgeting and Time Value of Money:

The capital budgeting process involves evaluating potential long-term investments. Here's the time value of money (TVM) concept in play:

  • TVM: A dollar today is worth more than a dollar tomorrow due to its earning potential.

  • Methods Considering TVM: Techniques like Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) factor in TVM by considering the cash flows of an investment over its entire life, discounted to their present value.

  • Method Not Considering TVM: Payback Period simply looks at how long it takes to recover the initial investment cost, ignoring the time value of money earned throughout the project's life.

  1. Quantitative vs. Qualitative Factors in Capital Budgeting:

Quantitative factors are measurable aspects like project costs, cash flows, and expected returns.

Qualitative factors are more subjective and can't be easily quantified. Examples include:

  • Market risk: The potential for changes in the market that could affect the investment's success.
  • Strategic fit: How well the investment aligns with the company's overall strategy.
  • Management expertise: The capabilities of the team managing the investment.

Sample Answer

     

Demystifying Budgeting and Decision Making

Let's dive into the world of budgeting, cost analysis, and making informed decisions!

  1. Budget Variance: A budget variance is the difference between what was budgeted (planned) for an expense or revenue and the actual amount incurred or generated. It can be favorable (positive variance - spending less than budgeted) or unfavorable (negative variance - spending more than budgeted).
  • Are budget variances good? Not necessarily. Favorable variances can indicate efficiency, but they might also signal unmet needs. Unfavorable variances can highlight overspending, but they could also reflect unforeseen circumstances.