Full Answer Section

Arguments for Failure:

• Trail of Tears: Jackson’s forced relocation of Native American tribes through the Trail of Tears resulted in immense suffering and death. He would likely face harsh criticism for this policy.
• Spoils System: Jackson’s implementation of the spoils system, where political appointments were based on loyalty rather than merit, could be seen as a step back from a meritocratic system.
• Limited Democracy: While promoting democracy for white men, Jackson did not advocate for rights for women, African Americans, or Native Americans.

Considering the Source:

• It’s important to remember Andrew Jackson was a product of his time. His views on race, democracy, and national expansion would likely reflect the prevailing attitudes of the early 19th century.

Overall:

Andrew Jackson’s presidency was a complex and controversial period. He would likely highlight his achievements in promoting democracy and national unity. However, his policies towards Native Americans and the spoils system would be major points of criticism.

By acknowledging both sides of the argument, you can present a balanced and well-rounded response to the question.